Andrew Huberman on Multivitamins
We include products we think are useful for our readers. If you purchase through links on this page, we may earn a commission. Learn more
Thinking about adding a multivitamin to your routine? Neuroscientist Andrew Huberman offers a nuanced perspective that goes beyond simply pill popping.
This post explores his views, emphasizing comprehensive support and addressing specific nutrients like Vitamin D and Magnesium, rather than relying solely on a standard multivitamin as the first step towards optimal health.
Why Multivitamins Might Fall Short
Individual needs vary significantly. Huberman shared needing 5,000-10,000 IU daily, while a relative required 30,000 IU, highlighting Dr. Rhonda Patrick’s key advice: "Measuring your vitamin D levels before and after supplementation is the only way you're gonna figure that out."
Standard multivitamin doses (often 400-1000 IU) may not correct deficiency or reach optimal levels for everyone, especially those with genetic variations (common SNPs) impairing conversion.
Testing reveals your baseline and how you respond to supplementation. While 1,000 IU typically raises levels by ~5 ng/ml, the optimal range for reducing all-cause mortality is suggested to be 40-60 ng/ml (insufficiency <30 ng/ml). Patrick aims for ~50 ng/ml with 5,000 IU daily.
Toxicity is rare and usually requires extremely high, prolonged doses. Therefore, while multivitamins provide some Vitamin D, achieving optimal levels often requires targeted supplementation guided by blood tests.
Multivitamins for Children and Dietary Gaps
The topic of multivitamins specifically for children stirs up many questions among parents. Is it necessary? Is it useful? And if not necessary, is it safe anyway?
According to Huberman, taking a multivitamin during childhood is generally safe. However, he doesn't believe everyone needs one. The necessity largely depends on individual dietary patterns. A standard multivitamin isn't automatically recommended for every child.
For those with more exclusionary diets, multivitamins may serve a legitimate purpose. If your child has celiac disease, for instance, they might miss out on certain nutrients found in gluten-containing foods. In such cases, supplementation through a multivitamin makes more sense to fill potential gaps.
Similarly, for women planning pregnancy in the near future, ensuring adequate nutrient levels is crucial. Huberman suggests a multivitamin (specifically, a prenatal formulation) could be reasonable in this context. This ensures adequate nutrient levels to support both maternal health and early fetal development.
The key takeaway regarding standard multivitamins, based on Huberman's perspective, is that they aren't universally required but can be situationally beneficial, particularly when specific dietary restrictions or life stages (like pre-pregnancy) might lead to nutritional gaps that need addressing
HUBERMAN SPONSOR
Momentous Multivitamin
• Provides a complete nutrient base
• Contains key vitamins and minerals in healthy doses
• Proven health benefits from phytonutrients
• Supports energy, immune function, and overall health
Foundational Health Over Standalone Multivitamins
Huberman explains why, when frequently asked about the single best supplement to take, he refrains from offering a simple answer like recommending a basic multivitamin. Instead, he initiates the conversation by asking three key questions.
The first question Huberman poses concerns the individual's sleep quality: Are they getting sufficient, restful sleep? He highlights that inadequate sleep necessitates a deeper discussion about corrective actions and potential supplements, given that sleep is the fundamental pillar of mental health, physical health, and performance.
The second question Huberman asks pertains to nutrition. He probes whether the person eats regularly, has identified a suitable diet or macronutrient combination, believes their vitamin and mineral intake is adequate, and how their digestion is functioning. This inquiry helps determine if nutritional deficiencies exist that might be addressed through supplementation, which could include, but isn't limited to, multivitamins.
The third essential question Huberman asks relates to the individual's budget for supplements. He points out that the advice differs significantly based on whether someone can allocate $10 or $1,000 per month. While a basic multivitamin might align with a smaller budget, it may not represent the most impactful initial step if greater financial resources are available.
Once these three factors—sleep, nutrition, and budget—are clarified, Huberman's recommendation, assuming a budget of around $100 or more per month, shifts away from focusing initially on any single supplement type, such as just a multivitamin.
He advises instead prioritizing the comprehensive buffering and enhancement of foundational nutrition, covering vitamins, minerals, adaptogens, probiotics, prebiotics, and digestive enzymes. Huberman argues that this approach broadly supports the biological and organ systems underpinning enhanced mental health, physical health, performance, and sleep, offering benefits beyond a typical multivitamin.
Therefore, if someone with a budget meeting the $100 threshold asks for a single supplement recommendation, Huberman suggests considering a comprehensive foundational formula like Athletic Greens (AG1) or similar products.
Alternatively, he advises they could invest the time and effort to research and combine individual components (vitamins, minerals, probiotics, prebiotics, adaptogens) to fulfill their foundational requirements. He notes that such comprehensive formulas inherently include the vitamin and mineral content of a multivitamin but provide much broader support.
Huberman acknowledges that most individuals are not inclined to undertake the extensive research and sourcing required for combining individual ingredients. He mentions his own use of Athletic Greens since 2012, citing personal benefits like enhanced energy, improved sleep and digestion, and gut microbiome support.
However, Huberman emphasizes that other excellent sources exist for obtaining the components found in foundational formulas like AG1. It is not the sole method for covering foundational health needs, which encompasses but extends beyond basic multivitamin coverage.
For individuals with a monthly supplement budget under $100, Huberman outlines different considerations. If the budget is zero, he stresses that the conversation must center on optimizing diet through food choices and eating patterns to best support health and performance. If the budget falls between $0 and $50 per month, the supplement discussion shifts. In this scenario, a well-formulated multivitamin might be considered as part of the strategy, although prioritizing diet remains the cornerstone.
Behavior and Whole Foods Before Multivitamins
When striving for optimal mental health, physical health, and performance, Andrew Huberman emphasizes a clear hierarchy of tools.
Layer 1: The Bedrock - Behavioral Tools
The absolute foundation of wellbeing, according to Huberman's perspective, consists of behavioral tools. These are specific actions we take—or deliberately avoid—that profoundly impact our biology without requiring the ingestion of any substance. Examples include:
Viewing sunlight shortly after waking up.
Engaging in regular physical exercise.
Avoiding bright light exposure between 10 pm and 4 am.
Steering clear of caffeine late in the day (e.g., after 2 pm).
These deliberate actions and avoidances form the essential first layer upon which all other health efforts should be built.
Layer 2: Nutrition - Fueling with Whole Foods
Building directly upon the behavioral foundation is nutrition. This layer cannot be overstated: no amount of supplementation, including multivitamins or other foundational formulas, can compensate for poor nutrition long-term.
While nutrition means different things to different people, encompassing various dietary approaches, the emphasis should be on obtaining the bulk of your nutrients from whole, unprocessed foods. This is critical because whole foods provide:
Essential Macronutrients and Energy: For basic bodily functions.
Crucial Fiber: Important for digestion and gut health.
Satiety: The physical bulk helps you feel full and manage appetite.
A Complex Spectrum of Micronutrients: Vitamins, minerals, essential fatty acids, and beneficial compounds like phytonutrients often work synergistically in whole foods – an effect difficult, if not impossible, to replicate solely with isolated compounds found in multivitamins or meal replacements.
Supplements can play a role here, but primarily as assistants, not replacements. For example, protein powders (whey, casein, plant-based) can help individuals meet specific protein intake goals (like the ~1g/lb body weight often cited by experts like Dr. Layne Norton) when it's difficult through diet alone. However, they still don't offer the full package provided by nutrient-dense whole foods.
Layer 3: Supplementation - The Role of Multivitamins
Only after establishing solid behavioral practices and a foundation of whole-food nutrition do we arrive at the third layer: supplementation. This is where multivitamins reside, alongside a vast array of other non-prescription compounds (individual amino acids, adaptogens, herbal extracts like green tea, etc.) designed for various purposes beyond simple nutrient replacement.
While multivitamins and other foundational supplements aim to fill potential gaps or provide targeted support, they should be viewed strategically. Relying solely on a multivitamin cannot replicate the complex, synergistic benefits of a nutrient-dense diet built on whole foods. The goal isn't to find one "magic" multivitamin that transforms health, but to understand if and where specific supplements might meet your needs better than behavior or nutrition alone, considering their interactions.
Layer 4: Prescription Medications
The fourth layer involves prescription medications obtained from a board-certified physician, which can be vital for managing specific health conditions.
Wrapping Up
In summary, Huberman stresses that supplements like multivitamins come after mastering behavioral tools and optimizing nutrition.
They can serve as an insurance policy or address specific deficiencies (like Vitamin D or Magnesium, best guided by testing), but aren't a cure-all or a substitute for healthy living.
HUBERMAN SPONSOR
Momentous Multivitamin
• Provides a complete nutrient base
• Contains key vitamins and minerals in healthy doses
• Proven health benefits from phytonutrients
• Supports energy, immune function, and overall health
FAQs About Multivitamins
What are the advantages of taking single-ingredient supplements over multi-ingredient formulas?
Single-ingredient formulations are essential for developing a rational, highly efficacious supplement regimen. They allow you to precisely adjust dosages based on your individual needs and responses, which isn't possible with pre-mixed blends. They also offer flexibility to cycle specific ingredients or take them on alternate days if needed. Crucially, this approach lets you determine if a specific ingredient actually works for you personally and makes it much easier to identify the cause if any side effects occur.
Why might a multi-ingredient foundational supplement be an exception to the single-ingredient preference?
Foundational supplements are generally considered the one category where multi-ingredient formulations can be appropriate and advantageous. Their purpose is to establish a baseline or provide "insurance" alongside your regular diet, ensuring you receive a broad spectrum of essential vitamins, minerals, and potentially other beneficial compounds (like enzymes or adaptogens) needed for basic health and performance. They aim to compensate for potential dietary deficiencies across multiple areas simultaneously.
Why is magnesium considered so important?
Magnesium is highlighted as crucial because about 40% of the US population is deficient. It's vital for vitamin D metabolism, ATP (cellular energy) production and utilization, and significantly, for DNA repair enzymes. Dr. Rhonda Patrick notes magnesium insufficiency can cause "insidious damage" daily because these critical repair mechanisms require magnesium as a cofactor to function optimally. This underscores why ensuring sufficient intake, potentially beyond typical multivitamin amounts, is important for foundational health.
What are the best food sources for magnesium?
Dr. Rhonda Patrick suggests remembering that magnesium is central to the chlorophyll molecule, which gives plants their green color. Therefore, dark leafy greens like kale, spinach, and Swiss chard are excellent dietary sources. Choosing these foods also provides other beneficial nutrients like calcium and vitamin K1.
Why is Vitamin D deficiency so widespread?
Vitamin D functions as a hormone primarily made via sunlight on skin, but production is highly variable. Factors like season, geographic location (less UVB in northern latitudes), skin melanin content (darker skin needs much more sun), sunscreen use, age (older individuals produce less), and modern indoor lifestyles significantly limit natural synthesis. Dr. Rhonda Patrick notes 70% of the US population has inadequate levels, indicating that standard multivitamin doses are often insufficient to overcome these common limitations.
Is Vitamin D just for bone health?
No, Vitamin D's role extends far beyond bone health. It acts as a steroid hormone regulating over 5% of the human genome. This impacts critical functions including serotonin production (important for mood), immune system regulation, and blood pressure. Furthermore, deficiency is linked to accelerated aging markers, as seen in both human studies and animal models, highlighting its profound systemic importance.
Why is simply taking the Vitamin D dose in a multivitamin often not enough?
Individual Vitamin D needs vary significantly due to genetics (SNPs affecting conversion), lifestyle, location, skin pigmentation, and baseline levels. Standard multivitamin doses (often 400-1000 IU) may not be sufficient to correct deficiency or reach optimal blood levels (suggested 40-60 ng/ml for reduced mortality risk) for many people. Huberman and Patrick emphasize blood testing as the only reliable way to determine the appropriate, often higher, personalized dose needed for optimal health.
How have foundational supplements evolved beyond basic multivitamins?
The world of foundational supplements has expanded significantly. While vitamins and minerals remain core components, many modern formulations now include additional ingredients like digestive enzymes (often ending in "-ase", like lipase) to aid nutrient absorption, and adaptogens (like Ashwagandha) which are compounds believed to help the body and brain better handle stress. This reflects a shift towards more holistic support, aiming to benefit multiple body systems simultaneously rather than just covering potential vitamin or mineral gaps.
What is the "expensive urine" argument about vitamin supplements?
Skeptics sometimes claim vitamin and mineral supplements merely produce "expensive urine." This refers to the fact that when you ingest high levels of water-soluble vitamins (like Vitamin C), your body excretes the excess in urine. However, this argument overlooks that many people aren't actually getting enough of these vitamins from their diet alone. While ingesting higher-than-needed amounts of most water-soluble vitamins is generally safe (within reason), a typical supplement can effectively cover deficiencies for those who need it.
How can I decide if I personally need a vitamin-mineral supplement?
The decision is highly individual and comes down to two main things. First, consider the cost – can you afford it and is it worth the price to you? Prices vary, often based on dosages and sourcing, though quality differences for standard vitamins might be less significant than perceived. Second, honestly assess your diet: are you consistently eating enough varied, whole foods to cover all your vitamin and mineral needs? If you are very physically or mentally active, or practice intermittent fasting (reducing overall food intake), a supplement might make more sense as an insurance policy.
Why is it often recommended to take vitamin supplements with food?
Taking supplements, especially vitamin-mineral formulas, with food is important primarily because many water-soluble vitamins, particularly B vitamins, can cause stomach upset if taken on an empty stomach (though individual tolerance varies). Additionally, some specific supplements like Zinc and Coenzyme Q10 are better absorbed or tolerated when taken with a meal. Taking supplements early in the day with food is often recommended.
Are there downsides to taking very high doses of vitamins and minerals?
Yes, taking exceedingly high doses is generally not recommended for two key reasons. First, fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, K) can build up in the body over time and potentially reach toxic levels. Second, relying on very high supplement doses might lead people to become complacent about their diet, spending less time and effort ensuring they get adequate nutrition from high-quality whole foods, which should always be the priority.
What kind of diet supports health best, regardless of using supplements like multivitamins?
Regardless of your specific dietary pattern (keto, vegan, omnivore, etc.), the key principle is to get the vast majority—around 75-80% or more—of your food intake from non-processed or minimally processed sources. This means prioritizing foods like fruits, vegetables, meats, eggs (which often require refrigeration or have short shelf lives) and minimally processed items like rice, oatmeal, pasta, and beans. Most experts agree that highly processed foods—those with long ingredient lists, preservatives, and long shelf lives like snack foods, pastries, and many canned goods—should be avoided as much as possible for optimal health and nutrition.